Ocarina of Time Review 1998: Why IGN Called It the Best

Revisit the Ocarina of Time review 1998 critics called era-defining — scores, quotes, innovations, and what still holds up today.

When IGN resurfaced its original Ocarina of Time review 1998 verdict in November 2026 — the one that crowned the N64 classic "easily the best in the series" — the post drew tens of thousands of likes and hundreds of heated comments within hours. Few pieces of games journalism from that era still generate this much friction. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time launched on Nintendo 64 on November 23, 1998, and the Ocarina of Time review cycle that followed didn't just hand out near-perfect scores; it rewired how the entire industry evaluated 3D games.

Why does a decades-old write-up still matter? Because every "legacy review" you read today borrows its playbook from 1998 — and because the remake conversation currently filling your feeds leans on that year's consensus for its legitimacy. This guide breaks down what critics actually said, which innovations earned the praise, and where community sentiment now pushes back.

What Did the Ocarina of Time Review 1998 Scores Actually Look Like?

The short answer: the ceiling broke. Major outlets didn't merely rate the game highly — several awarded the rarest score in their history. Here's how the 1998 coverage stacked up:

Outlet1998 ScoreNotable Context
IGN10/10Called it "easily the best in the series"
GameSpot10/10Perfect score, Game of the Year honors
Edge10/10Entered the magazine's tiny perfect-score club
Electronic Gaming Monthly10 / 10 / 9.5Near-sweep from the reviewer panel plus a Gold award
Famitsu (Japan)40/40The first perfect score in the magazine's history
Metacritic aggregate99/100Still the highest-rated game on the platform-wide site

That aggregate score deserves emphasis. Ocarina of Time remains the highest-rated game of all time on Metacritic, a record it has defended for nearly three decades against modern juggernauts. The title also swept Game of the Year awards, including honors from the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences, and sold more than 7 million copies on N64 hardware — remarkable for a console in a crowded 1998 holiday window that included Half-Life, Metal Gear Solid, and Banjo-Kazooie.

Why the 1998 Ocarina of Time Reviews Gushed: Five Innovations Critics Flagged

Reviewers in 1998 weren't just reacting to Zelda branding. They were reacting to solutions for problems that had plagued every early 3D release:

The 1998 3D ProblemOcarina of Time's Fix
Disorienting combat against moving enemiesZ-targeting lock-on system
Invisible interaction — what can I touch?Context-sensitive action button
Chaotic, player-hostile camerasCinematic auto-camera tied to lock-on
Empty, unmemorable open worldsRegion-based Hyrule with landmark navigation
Confusing level progressionChild/adult time-travel structure gating items to dungeons

Beyond the table, critics repeatedly praised elements that became series staples: Epona's horseback riding, a functional day/night cycle, an in-world music system where songs were literal gameplay verbs, and dungeon pacing that taught players new mechanics before testing them.

The Z-Targeting Asterisk

One caveat worth flagging comes from community reports rather than the 1998 coverage: sharp-eyed players note that Capcom's Mega Man Legends shipped in Japan in December 1997 with its own lock-on aiming mechanic, roughly a year earlier. The debate over who truly popularized versus who invented 3D lock-on continues in comment sections to this day. The fair reading: Mega Man Legends prototyped the idea; Ocarina of Time industrialized it and made it the genre standard.

"Easily the Best in the Series" — The Debate That Refuses to Die

IGN's 1998 line about Ocarina being "easily the best in the series" reads as near-unanimous praise for its time, but the November 2026 repost proved the ranking wars never ended. Player experience in the comments split into three familiar camps:

GameRelease YearSignature LeapCommunity Standing (Player Reports)
A Link to the Past1992 (NA)Refined the 2D formula to near-perfectionLoyal "best classic Zelda" camp remains vocal
Ocarina of Time1998Wrote the blueprint for 3D action-adventure designMost awarded, still the default answer
Majora's Mask2000Three-day time loop built on OoT's engineCult favorite; fans argue it's "also fire" and shouldn't be a competition

The Majora's Mask defense is the most interesting wrinkle in modern discourse. Community reports consistently show its supporters arguing that ranking the two games against each other misses the point — one is a landmark, the other is a bold experiment — yet the comparison resurfaces every time either title trends. Meanwhile, a persistent minority player experience holds that A Link to the Past never lost its crown, a take that was already common in 1998 and clearly hasn't surrendered since.

What Aged Like Wine — and What Reads Differently 28 Years Later

Reading the Ocarina of Time review 1998 language today is a time capsule exercise. Some claims held up completely; others require context:

Aged BeautifullyReads Differently Today
Z-targeting — now universal in 3D action games"Revolutionary graphics" praise (era-relative)
Dungeon design still studied by developersBoss difficulty — community reports call bosses too easy
Koji Kondo's score and diegetic song systemPerfect scores as a baseline expectation (score inflation)
Pacing and mechanical teaching structureLong load-time complaints (largely moot now)

The boss-difficulty critique deserves real weight. Community reports going back years describe the 1998 dungeon guardians as puzzle-first encounters rather than combat tests — satisfying in 1998, but a frequent "loved the game, wanted tougher fights" footnote in retrospective takes. And the near-universal 10s changed review culture itself: after 1998, a 10 stopped meaning "this is the best game ever made" and started meaning "this is the new benchmark." Commenters on IGN's repost captured the irony perfectly, with one noting the benchmark wasn't new at all — it was set almost 28 years ago.

Actionable Takeaways: How to Use the 1998 Reviews Today

Whether you're a player deciding where to start or a writer crafting your own retrospective, the 1998 coverage offers concrete lessons:

  • Date-stamp every claim. Graphics praise, control innovation, and even difficulty assessments are snapshots of available technology and audience experience. Never quote a 1998 verdict as a modern one.
  • Separate innovation from replay value. The 1998 reviews scored a breakthrough; your enjoyment today depends on tolerance for N64-era camera handling and inventory friction.
  • Cross-check the aggregate. A single outlet's 10 means less than a 99 Metacritic consensus built from two dozen critics.
  • Note the counterarguments. The Mega Man Legends lock-on debate and the Majora's Mask loyalty movement show how consensus forms — and what it quietly omits.

If you want to experience the original for yourself before (or after) sampling the remake, here's the current landscape:

PlatformYearNotes for Players
Nintendo 64 cartridge1998Original experience; complete-in-box copies command collector prices
GameCube (Collector's Edition disc)2003Emulated port bundled with other Zelda classics
Ocarina of Time 3D (3DS)2011Remaster with improved visuals and optional hints
Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack2021+Subscription access to the N64 version
Original Wii Virtual Console2007Discontinued; no longer purchasable

FAQ: Ocarina of Time Review 1998 — Questions Players Still Ask

Q: What score did the original Ocarina of Time review from 1998 give the game? IGN awarded a 10/10 and called it "easily the best in the series." GameSpot and Edge also issued perfect scores, while Japan's Famitsu famously granted the first 40/40 in the magazine's history. The aggregate landed at 99/100.

Q: Was Z-targeting really invented for Ocarina of Time? The mechanic was popularized by Ocarina, but community reports frequently point out that Mega Man Legends featured a lock-on system roughly a year earlier in Japan. Most historians credit Ocarina with standardizing lock-on across the industry rather than originating the concept outright.

Q: Did the 1998 review actually call it the best Zelda ever? Yes. IGN's 1998 verdict described the game as "easily the best in the series" — language the outlet deliberately re-shared in November 2026 alongside the remake's launch, which promptly reignited the A Link to the Past versus Majora's Mask versus Ocarina debate across social platforms.

Q: Why did IGN repost its Ocarina of Time review 1998 coverage in 2026? IGN tied the legacy review to the release of the new remake, using the 1998 quote to frame the original's benchmark status. The repost drew massive engagement, plus a predictable wave of skepticism from players who argued the outlet's modern credibility — and the remake's 9-out-of-10 score — fell short of the 1998 standard.

Nearly three decades on, the 1998 consensus still functions as gaming's reference point for what a generational leap looks like. Every time a remake, remaster, or "new benchmark" appears, critics and players reach back to that November — and, as the comment sections prove, they'll keep arguing about it for at least another 28 years.